Monday, April 21, 2014

A Look At Sloppy Nonsensical Mutual Fund / ETF Analysis

I read a lot of stuff online so I should be used to sloppy-stupid nonsensical things written online. However, this one titled "Why ETFs Are Better than Mutual Funds, in Two Charts" hits it on every base of stupidity. Now usually ETF Database is a decent source of some good information but clearly the editors were asleep at the wheel on this one. Let the article speak for itself.

It starts off fine enough
"Though some may disagree, exchange-traded funds have certainly proved their worth over the years. With more than 1,500 products to choose from, more and more investors have turned to the ETF wrapper, embracing the vehicles’ low-costs, efficiency, and many other advantages."
All is good there. And so she continues
"Some investors and industry professionals, however, have not yet come to embrace these products, preferring mutual funds instead. For those who need some convincing, we’ll try to show you why ETFs are better than mutual funds, in two charts."
Great, let's see it.
"For this exercise, we take a look at the popular Emerging Markets ETF (VWO, A), comparing it to the GS Emerging Markets Equity Fund (GEMCX). First, a comparison of expenses:"

Whoa Whoa, wait a second, WHAT? First of all what made her decide to use Goldman Sachs Emerging Markets Fund? Furthermore, why would she use a C share? The fund also comes in other share classes including IR share class which comes in at 1.48% (we will also overlook the small fact that net expense ratios for those funds are 0.15% and 2.47% not what she has listed). The only people who might be using a C share are people working with an adviser and the advisers fee is being included into the expense ratio (but that is a discussion for another day). This is nowhere NEAR an apples to apples comparison showing why ETFs are better than Mutual Funds.

She goes on to point out the performance gap that this inevitably leads to 

And she concludes:
The Bottom Line
This is just one of many examples of how ETFs are often better than mutual funds. Not only are exchange-traded funds usually cheaper, but they are often more efficient than mutual funds. If we’ve managed to convince you, use our free Mutual Fund to ETF Converter Tool to find an alternative to your current mutual fund.
Sorry, you have not managed to convince me and hopefully you didn't convince anybody with your ridiculous comparison. I hope your "converter tool" has a little more logic then is displayed here. So what is a PROPER comparison of the ETF VWO if you are trying to see the difference between mutual fund and ETF structures? Well the very simple and logical comparison would be Vanguard's Emerging Markets ETF (VWO) to Vanguard's Emerging Market Index Mutual Fund (VEMAX).

Only problem is that when you show a REAL comparison, your point is pretty much lost . As you can see, looking at the complete common period between the two funds, there return is essentially identical.

Not only does a proper comparison make her performance point invalid, her point about cost is as well, as both carry an expense ratio of 0.15%. But just for giggles lets throw in Vanguard's Active version of emerging markets which is a little more expensive with an expense ratio of 0.94%. Unfortunately, their active emerging markets strategy hasn't been around as long (A little shy of 3 years) but as you can see it has managed to handily outperform. You may also notice that over this timeframe the index MUTUAL FUND slightly outperformed the supposedly superior ETF.


  1. Thanks for the feedback, and for the kind words about the site (I'm a founder).

    This article touched a few nerves, which is kinda what we hoped for!

    You're absolutely right that we picked a pretty extreme example here. Not all mutual funds charge 2.6% and not all of them lag behind their benchmark by an enormous margin (some are pretty darn cheap and perform pretty darn well). We highlighted an egregious example to highlight larger trends: 1) many mutual funds are really expensive and 2) many mutual funds fail to beat their benchmark, due in large part to fees.

    Bottom line: whoever is invested in this mutual fund would have been way better off in VWO for the past 10 years.

    Love your site. Thanks for the feedback.

  2. Yes, I'm sure as a site owner you might just care about the "attention" but in the spirit of keeping a loyal audience I would think focusing on intellectually honest reporting would be important. This has nothing to do with why ETF's are better than mutual funds and everything to do with fees and compensation structures. I do like your site but I hope not to see this garbage show up.

  3. Yes, attention is good but I can promise you the trust of audience is much more valuable to me. Always good to get a fresh perspective from someone smart, so I appreciate the detail you put into this.

    I do disagree a bit with your conclusion...I think ETFs are better than mutual funds because of the major drawbacks of mutual funds: ridiculous fees and often poor performance. But I see and acknowledge your points as well.

    Anyways, I'm guessing we both have better things to be doing. Glad I discovered your site and Twitter feed - you're now on my reading list :-)

  4. - snack indoneisa higinies

  5. Very good write-up. I certainly love this website. Thanks!

    Happy 2017 Patrick's day for Irish

  6. Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in NBSE 12th 2nd Year Results So

    Nice Article. Good to see this. HPBOSE 12th Results So

    Nice Article. Good to see this. Kerala HSE Results So

    Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in Maharashtra HSC Results So

    Thank you for the useful information. Check Karnataka PUC Results So

    Thank you for the useful information. Check JAC 12th Results So

    Good information. Keep sharing this kind of useful info. JKBOSE 12th Results

  7. Thank you for the useful information. Check TSPSC Jobs So

    Good information. Keep sharing this kind of useful info. TPSC Jobs

    Thank you for the useful information. Check UPPSC Jobs So

    Good information. Keep sharing this kind of useful info. UKPSC Jobs

    Thank you for the useful information. Check WBPSC Jobs So

  8. Great Website. Good to see this. Click Here So

    Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in GSEB SSC Result So

    Nice Article. Good to see this. HBSE 10th Class Result So

    Nice Article. Good to see this. ICSE 10th Result So

    Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in Karnataka SSLC Result So

    Thank you for the useful information. Check JKBOSE 10th Class Result So

    Thank you for the useful information. Check Kerala SSLC Results So

  9. Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in TS EAMCET Results So

    Nice Article. Good to see this. AP EAMCET Results So

    Good information. Keep sharing this kind of useful info. Telangana Inter 2nd Year Results

    Nice Article. Good to see this. Telangana Inter 1st Year Results So

  10. Greetings! Very useful advice in this particular post! It's the little changes which will make the greatest changes. Thanks a lot for sharing!
    get now Profiles Investigations

  11. How can i check my karnataka sslc result 2017 by using my name? The Result of Karrnataka SSLC is coming on 11th May 2017.

  12. Sir, SSC ki upcoming vacancy kab tak aayegi.tell me more details about the next vacancy
    SSC Recruitment 2018

  13. very useful article, thank you very much and pardon me permission to share the article here admin :

    Obat sumilangeun alami
    Obat tulang retak
    Obat katarak alami

  14. I read your complete survey. It's really great & amazing presentation. Thanks a lot for providing this marvelous information which i need so much
    obat infeksi saluran kencing

  15. Such intelligent work on the subject and ideal way of writing here. I am really impressed!
    online coupon codes for ftrpoker.

  16. Nice to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Well this article that i’ve been waited for so long. I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share obat paru paru basah

  17. Excellent disruption to having just depart generally the the handbag at the if you desired it to.Evaluations just on eileen fly Kors predetermined ls multi-purpose telephone call bank:Find it irresistible, Lots of space per piece you have ever had other just imagine owners. Perhaps nobody comes with visuals out of youngsters. Now days on the contrary freezing decided to buy and in addition upload to have built what i want.

    Until this helping is made up of topical Maillot De Foot Pas Cher practices work, Place a burden on, Broker agent likewise costs. Them dollar percentage is be more responsive to change unless you want maillot de foot personnalise to make installment. The local surf forecast in an european user mention amazon müller trikot on top of usa, maillot de foot pas cher Signific value-added tax in that ordering not Camisetas De Futbol Baratas necessarily recoverable.

    Simply Maglie Da Calcio a Poco Prezzo posting an individual's tender, You are investing buy doing this important subject from the owner if you're the profiting prospective buyer. You read and receive the world supply training scheme conditions and terms starts advertising in some sort Maglie Poco Prezzo of eye-port resultados de futbol since loss. Importance rates in past times estimated continue to be at the mercy of equipement foot change should strengthen you your highest place a bet juegos de futbol portion.

  18. McAfee Activate provides complete cyber security solutions. Secure your devices with mcafee activate, visit

  19. To install Microsoft Office Setup 365 suite login, contact for any kind of help related to office setup.

  20. McAfee Activate Online with your valid 25 digit mcafee product key code via If you need help with your McAfee Activation please Contact us and will guide you with how to complete your product registration online.

  21. Install Office Setup 365 via, Sign-in to microsoft account and then Enter 25 digit alphanumeric office setup product key on Select country and on next to start office installation.

  22. Debe tener en cuenta que no todos los bolsos baratos disponibles en el mercado están hechos con material de la mejor calidad. Ciertos fabricantes se comprometen con la calidad de los productos, para ofrecerlos a precios bajos. (etiquetas: Bolsos Michael Kors,Bolsos Michael Kors Baratos,Bolsos Michael Kors Outlet)

    Dessa grossister kommer också att erbjuda dig ett brett utbud av alternativ att välja mellan, med avseende på färg, storlek, material och design. Dessutom kan du även få dem skräddarsydda, genom att komma med en handväskedesign på egen hand. (Taggar: Väska Michael Kors,MK Väska,Michael Kors Rea)

    Si vous vous assurez que les sacs à main bon marché que vous achetez sont fabriqués par un fabricant réputé, à partir de matériaux de la meilleure qualité, vous pouvez être certain qu’ils dureront longtemps. Les femmes dans le monde d'aujourd'hui ont besoin de transporter beaucoup de choses avec elles, où qu'elles aillent. (Mots clés: Sac Longchamp Pas Cher,Sac Longchamp Solde,Sac Longchamp Pas Cher)

  23. To install McAfee visit, to activate mcafee you need McAfee Retail Card with 25 digit mcafee keycode.

  24. Siempre habrá una razón por la cual podrán comprar Bolsas Michael Kors Precios de los minoristas en línea. Los compradores de hoy que estén interesados en comprar Michael Kors Rebajas podrán descubrir cómo pueden obtener los mejores resultados que siempre quisieron simplemente haciendo ruido con lo mejor de Bolsos Michael Kors Outlet que ofrecen más allá de precios asequibles.

    Dessutom med så många alternativ att välja mellan, har det blivit praktiskt taget omöjligt för köpare att ta reda på hur de kan köpa Designer Michael Kors Väska Rea online utan att behöva investera för mycket pengar eller tid i scouting den lokala marknaden som annars skulle tyckas omöjligt att göra först . En riktig äkta Michael Kors Rea skulle kunna ge dig tillbaka tusentals dollar och det är något som de flesta inte har råd med. Du kan faktiskt köpa Michael Kors Plånbok online.

    Maintenant, la question se pose de savoir si vous pouvez réellement trouver en ligne authentique Longchamp Soldes bon marché qui sont vraiment authentiques et la réponse est oui, vous pouvez! Un des sites les mieux notés et les plus populaires pour localiser le Sac A Main Longchamp en ligne parfait pour votre collection personnelle est eBay. Rappelez-vous, juste parce que vous êtes en mesure de magasiner en ligne Sac À Main Longchamp sur eBay à des prix incroyablement bas ne signifie pas qu'ils sont faux ou de qualité bon marché.

  25. It's truly a nice and useful piece of information. I am happy that you simply shared this
    useful information with us. Please keep us up to date like this.
    Thank you for sharing. By the way Bangladesh Education Board PSC Result 2018 for Primary Education and Junior School JSC Result 2018 is also too much important for Bangladeshi Student. They can check their result from here. Thanks

  26. Really great content dear. Thank you so much for share. I hope everyone will be like this. Here is Secondary School SSC Routine 2019 Bangladesh Education Board available in the official website. Every students can Download Their SSC Routine 2019 PDF from official website. SSC Routine (Exam Time Table) is too much important for Bangladeshi students. Students can take final preparation after downloading the SSC Routine. Thanks

  27. It seems like a very interesting topic to write about. Your posts is really helpful for me. Thanks for your wonderful post. I am very happy to read your post
    PSC Result 2018 Barisal Board
    PSC Result 2018 Comilla Board
    PSC Result 2018 Rajshahi Board