Sunday, February 17, 2013

Performance of Morningstar's New Analyst Ratings For Mutual Funds in 2012

Last year I wrote about Morningstar's new analyst ratings for mutual funds (here as well). These are different from their Star Ratings in the fact that these are meant to be "forward looking". From Morningstar (bold added by me)
"The Analyst Rating is based on the analyst's conviction in the fund's ability to outperform its peer group and/or relevant benchmark on a risk-adjusted basis over the long term. If a fund receives a positive rating of Gold, Silver, or Bronze, it means Morningstar analysts think highly of the fund and expect it to outperform over a full market cycle of at least five years."
Now it should be clear that these ratings are longer-term in nature so take the following breakdown with a grain of salt but I said I would follow-up on these so I am.

First lets start with a review of what the distribution of Morningstar's Analyst Ratings looked like at the start of 2012
While the distribution of ratings has gotten a little better it remains a mystery why Morningstar has an allergic reaction to assigning negative ratings. As of the start of 2013 they have now rated 1069 funds but only 52 (or less then 5%) have negative ratings. Although the neutral ratings have increased to 28%, Bronze to 25%, Silver is down to 24% and Gold down to about 18%.

Without further ado, below is how the rated funds performed in 2012. These only include funds rated at the start of 2012.

Not much really stands out after the first year. While their was a slight positive result for Gold and Silver rated funds, Neutral rated funds did even better. As for Bronze and Negative rated funds, outperformance was pretty much a coin flip.

Below is the Average Rank for each, as you can see Neutral rated funds performed the best and Negatively rated funds performed the worst.

Take this for what it's worth, which at this point is not much because full market cycles are indeed a better measuring stick. For instance, in 1999 and 2006/2007 a lot of bad managers did good thinking the unsustainable was in fact sustainable while a lot of good managers did bad as they realized irrationality when they saw it. However, this is at least a starting point for looking at the performance of these Analyst Ratings.


  1. Well, we'll have to wait for a full cycle but it isn't looking too good for Morningstar thus far. At best you might say they seem to be able to inconsistently flag one bad type of fund.

  2. It is nice to see these analytic ratings for mutual fund and what is the present rating of this mutual fund.

  3. The information was unbelievably amazing. Thanks a lot for posting it. movers and packers marathahalli Movers and packers madhapur

  4. Using writing personal tender, You are investing in buy this one element from the vendor if you're succeeding prospective buyer. You read and concure with the worldwide taking solution fine print goes into business in a unique pane quite possibly loss. Scan penalty service fees during the past estimated might be susceptible to change so long as you add to you most efficient purchase sum of money..

    That Maillot De Foot Pas Cher level also contains it applies persuits requirements, Place a burden on, Stock broker as well fines. This type of volume Maglie Calcio Poco Prezzo is Maglie Da Calcio a Poco Prezzo at the mercy of change unless you want Camisetas De Futbol Baratas to make costs. maillot de foot personnalise For vacationer tax, See the worldwide offering product finer points starts in the right truck's pickup truck's windshield alternatively bill.

    All of your number Coach Outlet Online Store presents related manners needs, hummel trikots Taxation's, Brokerage firm properly as other service expenses. This excellent money is be governed by change before resultados de futbol make expenses. The local surf forecast in an european union manhood express chance usa, Signific value-added tax on amazon müller trikot this subject selection isn't recoverable dfb trikot müller.

  5. You possibly can also order the Michael Kors Factory Outlet on the web via several different on the net firms, just proceed with caution when purchasing Michael Kors Bags Outlet - as you would with anything else - on the web. The assortment is fantastic for anyone looking for a Michael Kors Outlet Online, and you'll find constantly new and a lot more modern Michael Kors Handbags Outlet being released. They are many of the top labels for designer Michael Kors Outlet Online. Designer Michael Kors Bags Outlet are often thought of as a status symbol. If you have a designer Michael Kors Handbags On Sale, you prefer to have the best of everything. Designer Michael Kors Bags On Sale are made to be as unique as the people who carry them. Most of the Michael Kors Handbags Clearance come in very bright colors with flashy accents or details because part of the purpose of carrying a designer Michael Kors Outlet Store is to show it off.

  6. This is such a cool blog, atleast content has a meaning unlike those useless blogs on the internet.Happy Independence Day India Quotes