Wednesday, August 1, 2012

Morningstar Continues Rollout of Analyst Mutual Fund Ratings, Only 7% Negative.

Morningstar has been rolling out it's new "forward looking" analyst ratings for mutual funds since last November as I have touched on before. The number of funds rated has gone from 349 funds to 924 as of the end of the 2nd quarter (You can see the full list as of 6/30/12 here). While it has been good to see the distribution of ratings even out somewhat, Morningstar still appears to have an allergic reaction to rating funds "negative" as can be seen below.

As a reminder about the meaning of the ratings, per Morningstar....
"The Analyst Rating is based on the analyst's conviction in the fund's ability to outperform its peer group and/or relevant benchmark on a risk-adjusted basis over the long term. If a fund receives a positive rating of Gold, Silver, or Bronze, it means Morningstar analysts think highly of the fund and expect it to outperform over a full market cycle of at least five years."
After reading that you might assume that anything rated gold, silver or bronze is a fund Morningstar analysts think will provide risk-adjusted outperformance compared to a relevant benchmark over a full market cycle of atleast 5 years. Apparently can be seen by the majority of ratings given to 29 index funds. Obviously you could not expect an index fund to outperform it's relevant benchmark....after all, index funds are designed to REPLICATE their relevant benchmark. So they should generally perform in line with the benchmark, minus fees. The best an index fund can hope to do is meet Morningstar's definition of neutral "Fund that isn’t likely to deliver standout returns, but also isn’t likely to significantly underperform".

Despite the fact that by their very nature index funds can't be expected to outperform their relevant benchmark, of the 29 index funds Morningstar rated, the ratings breakdown as follows: 14 Gold, 9 Silver, 3 Bronze, 2 Neutral, 1 Negative. It is true that the majority of actively managed mutual funds underperform their benchmarks as can be seen below (you can see more in S&P's Indicies vs Active Report). However, the reality is index funds always underperform their benchmarks! (unless a sampling error works in their favor).

However, what Morningstar should take away from the above info is not that index funds deserve metal ratings, what they should take away is that they need to be much more stingy in giving away Gold, Silver & Bronze....because the majority of mutual funds, ACTIVE & PASSIVE, underperform their benchmarks! If everyone knew that metal ratings only meant they would perform like their benchmark I doubt anyone would care for that information, yet Morningstar thinks that is exactly what they should do.


  1. Welcome to the Lake Wobegone Olympics - where 2/3 of the competitors get medals :)

    This would be more useful if gold,silver and bronze were reserved for the consensus 3 best managed funds in a given category. If all the mangers suck, give the medals to the best ETFs.

  2. How to select a Mutual Fund? and Pls give some information on mutual fund, which mutual fund is good to invest?

  3. Your blog is just so cool. It’s very useful blog, I am sure that they will definitely find all the help that they need from you.

  4. Of the many blogs that I follow (obat maag untuk ibu hamil), not many blogs whose content like this, I was blessed to find this blog (obat ulu hati perih). Thank you for offering variety of interesting articles, are also useful. cara mengobati ginjal bengkak

  5. I can only express a word of thanks! Nothing else. Because with the content on this blog you can add knowledge. Thank you very much for sharing this information. AvriqAvriq India

  6. This guidance serving does include important traditions projects, Income income tax, Broker as well fines. Which presence is susceptible to change unless you make agreed paying. The local surf forecast in an european union user say possibility states, Scan value-added tax with this pick out not really recoverable.

    Any existing meeting place postage Maglie Calcio Poco Prezzo and packing pays simply Maglie Da Calcio a Poco Prezzo with regard regarding Pitney Bowes corporation. Here is additional information goes into business in a whole new pane hummel trikots or tabIf for any excuse your maillot foot 2018 not completely enthusiastic about you buy the car, You are welcome to roi the product or service(s) On the manuel neuer trikot rot inside of 14 days(20% restocking cost 'll exercise.) The goods(s) Has camisetas de futbol baratas to be inside basic, maillot de foot pas cher Vacant, Branded, For the reason that directed appearance. If, perhaps for any excuse, The product Maillot De Foot Pas Cher or service is not in that issue Maglie Poco Prezzo as rrt had been when maillot de foot personnalise ever distributed, We will struggle to treatment the come back and the product or service to become delivered back by the people today value.

  7. Se acerca el Mundial de Rusia 2018 y comprar camisetas de futbol con él una nueva oportunidad de vivir momentos de maillot antoine griezmann france 2018 intenso, de espectáculo de primer orden,david de gea camiseta de sentimientos y militancias.No es una guerra menor,Cristiano Ronaldo el negocio es interesante porque generan mucha necesidad entre el aficionado (cómo no ir con los colores con los que me identifico)partidos de futbol hoy y son un negocio rentable. No es una guerra menor,futbol primera division el negocio es interesante porque generan mucha necesidad entre el aficionado (cómo no ir con los colores con los que me identifico)fotos de futbol y son un negocio rentable. La jornada de futbol con la que participará este año la selección nigeriana en el Mundial ha tenido muy buena acogida. No es la única zamarra que ha causado sensación en la historia de los Mundiales. Artículos de coleccionista,replicas camisetas futbol objetos de deseo, fetiches… las Cristiano Ronaldo camisetas son uno de los elementos que más pasiones genera de los que no están estrechamente vinculados al juego.