Wednesday, September 22, 2021

No, Covid Breakthrough Cases Are NOT Less Severe

It amazes me how easily a talking point can take hold despite little to no data to support the claim. At first the pitch regarding the vaccine was a straightforward one. Get the vaccine because it will prevent you from getting Covid and stop the spread. In fact, on March 29th the CDC director explicitly said as much.


Now the narrative has changed and they admit that vaccinated people can get covid and can spread Covid just as easily as unvaccinated…..But now they are claiming over and over again (and the media is repeating) that when someone does get a breakthrough case it results in much less severe outcomes.



But this just doesn’t match-up with the facts. The problem with getting to the bottom of this, however, is that the CDC stopped collecting data on breakthrough cases back in May unless they resulted in hospitalization or death. Because of this you can’t find reliable countrywide data on the percent of breakthrough cases that result in hospitalization or death because you don’t have the denominator.

Also, as pointed here “Holes in reporting of breakthrough Covid cases hamper CDC response”. In many places even the reporting of hospitalizations and deaths is drastically under-reported….so when the media reports aggregate numbers on those they are highly skewed resulting in vaccinated deaths likely being labled unvaccinated because the vaccination status cannot be identified. (some keys from that article are below).





But what happens when we look into some local areas that ARE supposedly reporting this data accurately? We find that once a breakthrough case happens….severe outcomes are NOT dramatically reduced. Let’s take a look at Virginia


So the chance of hospitalization after breakthrough is 927/23344 or 4.0%. This compares to all cases since the start of the pandemic in Virginia of 4.3%. In other words if you get a breakthrough case you have a whopping 0.3% less chance of going to the hospital. For deaths it is 1.0% for breakthrough and 1.5% for all cases (although this counts cases since the start of the pandemic when there were no real treatment options).

How about Washington State? Per their report from September 22nd (breakthrough data through the 11th)


And this compares to their total cases over the whole pandemic seen below


So breakthrough cases resulting in hospitalization in Washington State has actually been 9% compared to 5.6% for all cases…..so actually MORE likely to end up in the hospital if you come down with a breakthrough case in this instance. Death rate is 0.9% for breakthrough cases and 1.2% for all cases. Interestingly enough…..if you count all cases since the same date as the breakthrough calculation Jan 17th — Sept 11th, you actually get pretty much exactly the same death rate as breakthrough (0.9%). Most states don’t let you slice the numbers this way but it makes since that the total death rate would go down as more treatment options became available. This doesn’t sound like the dramatic reduction in severe outcomes once someone comes down with a breakthrough case like fauci was talking about.

Another example? How about Oregon. Per their report from September 16th (with data through September 11th)


That means that 4.7% of their breakthrough cases resulted in hospitalization and 0.9% resulted in death. This compares to their TOTAL cases since the pandemic began of 5.4% hospitalization rate and 1.1% that resulted in death (again including the start of the pandemic which had higher death rates due to less treatment options).


You may have looked at the age range of the breakthrough cases and said..oh but most of the breakthrough deaths are older! Majority of ALL deaths are older! In fact, 94% of all deaths since the start of the pandemic have been 50+ and 77% have been 65+.



So we have looked at 3 states data (those that supposedly track this data properly) and have found that breakthrough cases that result in hospitalization was 4% in Virginia, 4.7% in Oregon and 9% in Washington State….compared to 4.3%, 5.4% and 5.6% for all cases since the start of the pandemic. And Breakthroughs that result in death was 1% in Virginia, 0.9% in Oregon and 0.9% in Washington compared to 1.5%, 1.1% and 1.1%.

I don’t know about you but I think I know why they don’t give us actual numbers on the outcomes of breakthrough cases when they give this talking point. The reality is if you get a breakthrough case, your outcome is likely to be quite similar to that of a unvaccinated person. The reason that breakthrough deaths and hospitalizations are less overall is simply because the vaccines still have some efficiancy in reducing your odds of getting it in the first place…..Nowhere NEAR the efficacy that was originally advertised as new varients emerge, and effectiveness quickly falls over time (most studies show under 50% after 6 months) but some efficacy nonetheless, but that is the reason for reduced severe cases….NOT that breakthroughs are dramatically less severe once you get it.




70 comments:

  1. There is no way to get this useful info . Its very fabulous and easy for me to get it from FMWhatsApp. I am very thankful and I appreciate your intelligent work. Awesome!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Welcome to the new generation in mobile online cricket games every cricket games lover can get all news, views, run, wicket required run rate
    and many more information at fantasypower11.
    play cricket online

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is really good news. check our best psychiatrist in cleveland ohio.Depression Psychiatrist in Cleveland

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for sharing the information.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This is a very beautiful place.also visit

    https://www.canva.com/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nice and valuable information, Thanks for sharing, Also visit daraz for millions of products.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Very nice and well articulated work..
    Do check some awesome luxury properties in dehradun.
    Properties in dehradun
    Visit: https://www.sumeruinfrastructures.com/1-bhk

    ReplyDelete
  9. Now- a-day more people are wants to earn money by fantasy app, where fantasypower11 is provide to opportunity to play
    cricket online and earn money.
    play cricket online

    ReplyDelete
  10. As the world leader in Engineering Solutions , Engineering Service and construction of onshore long-distance oil and gas pipelines along with the industry’s premier storage solution for crude oil and other petrochemicals; fast engineers and fabrications have years of proven expertise and experience even in complex conditions. With regard to long-distance pipeline construction, we have mastered an entire set of design and construction technologies for pipelines. Our main motto is customer satisfaction with our Fabrication Services, Site Erection Services and many more.
    more infomation:- https://fastengineers.in/

    ReplyDelete

  11. Hello I am so delighted I located your blog,
    This is my UFA077 and it has been very helpful.
    The biggest bonus you can get on this ufa077 is always the biggest bonus you can get if you are an active member of this site,
    and you don't have to worry about it as this is the best and most trusted site.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Need Personalized Business Products or personalized custom products for staff members and for brand promotions we some best-personalized products ideas for you. Put your company logo on mugs, pens and t-shirts make it your special organization gift. Gift personalized products help you in brand and company promotions on a bigger scale. Such logoed promotional items to customers and workers will expand the range of your organization to a higher level.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks for sharing a  lot of information. this information help me a lot. lets come to my site www.GitHub.com a for lot of information. Thanks you. 

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thank you for sharing such an useful information.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hello Thanks for sharing lots of information. Here is Men’s Tan Work Boots For Sale.

    ReplyDelete
  16. The oil can be used in conditions with extremely high cooking temperatures. It may also help food stay fresher and healthier for longer periods of time.
    Buy Refined Sunflower Oil online

    ReplyDelete
  17. Best post i have ever Seen,keep it up guys … I will follow you for more new posts.
    Buy best mystery romance books UAE

    ReplyDelete
  18. Unified Brand Clothing was born at the intersection of style and technology. Thanks to our inspiring collections and our impeccable customer service, we have been highly successful since day one. Browse through our site and check out the latest additions to our collection, and feel free to get in touch with our team if you need any assistance. Happy shopping!

    ReplyDelete
  19. Very good quality. I am surprised how many attempts you set to make such an excellent informative website.
    good books to read for adults

    ReplyDelete
  20. Very good quality. I am surprised how many attempts you set to make such an excellent informative website.

    best young adult books

    ReplyDelete
  21. Nice Blog! Here, I want to post a informative blog for Pharma Business in Maharashtra
    PCD Pharma Franchise Company in Maharashtra

    ReplyDelete
  22. Laihas Bohemian Dreaming - L.B.D Boho Jewellery Australia

    High Quality Artisan Made Jewellery. Designer Gemstone, Sterling Silver

    and Gold Vermeil Jewellery Online. A large range of Unique Bohemian

    Jewellery Online, offering Rings, Necklaces, Earrings, Anklets and more.

    Designed By Hand, Made By Hand Hypoallergenic.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Very good quality. I am surprised how many attempts you set to make such an excellent informative website.

    buy online books in UAE

    ReplyDelete
  24. It's really nice! thank you for sharing.lessburn offers various services like Business Information Sourcing, Market Research, Digital Marketing, Search Engine Optimization, Social Media & Email Marketing Campaigns, Creative Designs, Explainer Videos, UI/UX, Mob & Web Application Development.

    ReplyDelete

  25. Top Cloud Computing Training in Noida

    Are you looking for Cloud Computing Certification and Training institute in Noida? ShapeMySkills.pvt .ltd provides you a list of Top Cloud Computing Training in Noida. AWS Cloud Computing training Noida, is one of the upcoming and most popular technology driven courses in Noida and other major cities of India. Best Cloud Computing Training in Delhi & Training Institute in Delhi. Best Cloud Computing training in noida 4.9 out of 5 based on 3000 ratings.

    https://shapemyskills.in/courses/cloud-computing/

    ReplyDelete
  26. good keep it up very.... good post i have ever see,keep itup guys... i will follow you for more posts.
    Online romance Series Shop UAE

    ReplyDelete
  27. good keep it up very.... good post i have ever seen,keep itup guys... I will follow you for more posts.
    Schutzmasken

    ReplyDelete
  28. The pandemic has entirely changed the way of working. Most of us work with common web conferencing software like Google Meet, Microsoft Teams, and Zoom to discuss the project. During the conference call, you may face external challenges like noise distortion, network connectivity, communication lag, and other background noises. For getting rid of the background trouble during your conference call, you can use the background noise removal app for better sound quality.
    try our innovative noise cancellation software FREE for 30 days
    background noise cancelling software
    noise cancelling software
    noise cancelling software for windows

    ReplyDelete
  29. This software is 100% effective and enhances the voice quality of virtual conference calls. Claerityai offers a free trial Noise cancelling software for 30 days, so you can install the software on your device and try it. Noise-canceling AI technology helps to eliminate the background noise in the conference and virtual calls that make the call more productive.

    noise cancelling app for windows
    free noise cancelling software

    ReplyDelete
  30. This AI-powered tool provides you with complete control over your virtual meetings, including noise and echo reduction, background noise cancelling software while retaining complete confidentiality and Flexibility.
    noise cancelling software

    ReplyDelete
  31. Work from home (WFH), Study and Learning from Home (SFH), social distancing are the new realities of our life. Professionals taking official conference calls, and teaching staff and children attending online classes often feel embarrassed due to the background noises, which at times, are totally unavoidable. Such noise distractions result in mostly repeat conversations and productivity loss According to a recent CMR survey, more than 30% of noise cancelling software users consider audio echoes and voice clarity the most common issues affecting web conferencing. This gap has flared conversations around efficient productivity software.

    noise cancelling app for windows

    ReplyDelete
  32. Very helpful information and thanks for sharing.
    Adhiban Nidhi offers a wide range of Fixed Deposit (FD), Recurring Deposit (RD) & Monthly Investment Schemes Fixed Deposit in Coimbatore at attractive interest rates with assured returns.

    ReplyDelete
  33. good keep it up very.... good post i have ever seen,keep itup guys... I will follow you for more posts.
    Bundhosen

    ReplyDelete
  34. good keep it up.... I want to give some infomation For your business. Best IVR Service Provider in India

    ReplyDelete
  35. Very good quality. I am surprised how many attempts you set to make such an excellent informative website.
    literature books sale UAE

    ReplyDelete
  36. family mediator service in north of england

    ReplyDelete
  37. I’m really happy to say it was an interesting post to read. I learned new information from your article on nmims organisational behaviour assignment, you are doing a great job

    ReplyDelete
  38. Online romance Series Shop UAE... While her country and those dearest to her pay the terrible price of war, Alex learns the art of espionage
    Online romance Series Shop UAE

    ReplyDelete
  39. Wow you are providing Too much Best information! I will appreciate if you check my blog about radio live
    I bookmark your site for future read

    ReplyDelete
  40. Great Content, I really recommend your blog with my co-workers. And I also take some points from your blog to my website. You can also visit our website at Best property dealer in Chandni Chowk
    Thank You

    ReplyDelete
  41. thanks dear for this website information
    Rishikul College Gurugram: Home https://rishikulcolleges.org

    ReplyDelete
  42. this article is very helpful thanks for sharing informative ideas and blogs.

    ReplyDelete
  43. very.... good post i have ever seen,keep itup guys... I will follow you for more posts.

    Arbeitsshorts

    ReplyDelete
  44. Thanks for the detailed article on this topic. I would like to see more such awesome articles from you.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Fantastic blog! Thanks for sharing a very interesting post, I appreciate to blogger for an amazing post.

    Sewer Cleaning
    Home Drainage Cleaning

    ReplyDelete
  46. Amazing....
    "Latest Govt Jobs Online Form, Result, Answer Key 2021-2022 : Job Place.com provides latest Job Result , Online Form, Sarkari jobs result 2021 .Result in job place various sectors such as , Bank job, SSC,Rojgar Samachar, Police, UPPSC, UPSSSC, UPTET,Railway bank, haryana police exam date 2022 UP Scholarship and other Private and Sarkari job alerts at one place job place.

    https://jobplace.in/

    ReplyDelete
  47. This AI-powered tool provides you with complete control over your virtual meetings, including noise and echo reduction, background noise cancelling software while retaining complete confidentiality and Flexibility.
    noise cancelling software
    noise cancelling software for windows

    ReplyDelete
  48. claerityai is a Noise Cancellation Software used by hundreds of working professionals who require professional audio output in their online meetings. claerityai uses an innovative and patented noise reduction technique that enhances audio quality by recognizing and filtering audio signals that the speaker's vocal stream can't generate.
    Free Noise Cancellation App
    Background Noise Removal App
    noise cancellation app

    ReplyDelete
  49. Claerityai works across numerous tools such as Zoom, Teams, Google Meet, and others. Noise Cancellation Software The tool helps people who face challenges with unwanted background noise while working from home with benefits reaped through innovative AI technology. It is available for different sectors like the private sector, public sector, IT, education, healthcare, finance, and many more.
    Noise reduction software
    Noise Cancelling Software for Windows & Mac

    ReplyDelete
  50. Nice and Thanks for this valuable information. Thanks for sharing. You can also visit gettechengineering.blogspot.com for more tech related information.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Students have suffered the most in this pandemic, so now take your school and institute on the online platform. with edneed you can make a stunning website within 2 minutes for your institute.
    Visit - https://blog.edneed.com/make-a-stunning-website-within-2-minutes-for-your-institute/

    ReplyDelete
  52. Nice and valuable information, Thanks for vist amzon.com for buy a product.   

    ReplyDelete
  53. Very interesting and informative content, thanks for sharing. Also, visit Royal Garage Door to buy quality doors

    ReplyDelete
  54. This Blog is Very Informative. Please Keep writing. We White Label GPS Tracking Software Provider and Fleet Management Software for Your Vehicles Tracking. Accelerate your fleet management business with the leading GPS Tracking Software.

    ReplyDelete