Monday, December 12, 2016

Why Do Unified Republican Governments Always Lead to Crisis?


While I believe the purpose of these types of headlines and tweets are to illicit positive emotions, readers would be well advised to look up the DISASTROUS history of extended periods of unified Republican governments. 

In fact, the ONLY 3 PERIODS of extended unified Republican governments going back to 1900 ALL DIRECTLY led to banking crises....Arguably the 3 worst in US History. To be clear, I am defining 'extended' unified governments as anytime they control the House, Senate and White house for at least 4 years. This does not include short 2 year stints since it's hard to screw things up that quick (FYI there was only 1 period of that anyway, 1953-1955). You can look up the periods yourself here and more detail here.

The list of Unified Republican Government crises include the Panic of 1907The Great Depression, and the Financial Crisis of 2007-2008. Interestingly, the record of extended Republican control of Congress has also only led to crises. There have only been 4 periods of extended Republican control of Congress (3 of which overlap with the periods of full unified control just mentioned). However, the 4th period (I KID YOU NOT) ended in the 2000 DotCom Bust where the Republicans controlled the House and Senate from 1995-2001.

In short, full Republican control has NO history of making America great...let alone AGAIN. Don't feel like checking out that history yourself? Here's what you'll find....
Technically Republicans took control in 1895 but this graph does not start there. And While I mentioned the Panic of 1907......I will just brush off the Panic of 1901. Markets fell over 43% before bottoming after both events. How they were not thrown out until 1911 is anyone's guess.

Then we have the Great Depression fuelled by the unsustainable laissez-faire polices of the roaring 20's.
Only led to the greatest market decline in history and total social devastation.....Is that the type of "Great" we want to make again? 

Oh and then we have the Financial Crisis of 2007-2008
This case meets the minimum for "extended" by getting to 4 years (although technically they almost had 6 full years as only 1 independent tipped the senate democrat in 2001). Again lax regulations created the housing bubble which popped in 2006 and lead to our famous bank failures and financial crisis. (Case Shiller housing price index)

While the Republicans managed to get kicked out of Congress in 2007 the coming disaster was already well in motion by then.

While that wraps up the History of the 3 worst banking crises in American History...or um....I mean the History of the "Unified Republican Government". It would not be complete without completing it with the final piece to the history of the extended Republican control of Congress....which is only complete with the DotCom Bust of 2000.
There we have it folks! The disastrous history which has accompanied EVERY extended Unified Republican Government (or control of congress) since 1900. Think I'm missing a period that didn't end in disaster? Check for yourself. I'm not.

19 comments:

  1. Very interesting. An analysis of how folks of different economic strata fared might also be of interest.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Democrat administrations produced major wars (WWI, WWII, Korea, Vietnam).

    Both Democrat and Republican administrations have produced recessions:

    Theodore Roosevelt (R) - 36 months
    Howard Taft (R) - 24 months
    Woodrow Wilson (D) - 48 months
    Harding/Coolidge (R) - 14 months
    Calvin Coolidge (R) - 14 months
    Herbert Hoover (R) - 43 months
    FDR - 21 months
    Harry Truman - 11 months
    Dwight Eisenhower - 28 months
    Kennedy/LBJ - 0 months
    LBJ - 0 months
    Nixon/Ford - 27 months
    Jimmy Carter - 6 months
    Ronald Reagan - 16 months
    George H W Bush - 8 months
    Bill Clinton - 0 months
    George W Bush - 26 months
    Barack Obama - 0 months

    I don't think an American President has any control over the economy, it is the outcome of war, technological change, and market forces.

    Bill Clinton inherited a peace dividend from the end of the Cold War.

    George W Bush inherited the 9/11 and poured trillions into wars in Iraq, Afghanistan, and the war on terror here at home.

    Obama took most of the US troops out of the Middle East, and largely did little to combat the war on terror, and ISIS terrorist attacks have spread into Europe and the United States.

    Trump campaigned on going after terrorists, which will take more money still. Let us all hope this effort is successful, and if so, will lead to economic prosperity here in the US and abroad.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. First you should realize I personally dislike both Republican & Democrats. This is more an observation about the results of periods of not having enough pushback via checks and balances on a party which favors deregulation.

      However, since your talking about GDP here they are by term but only going back 16 terms
      [IMG]http://i63.tinypic.com/2lwol5f.jpg[/IMG]

      Also during those terms Republicans had 4.6 qtrs of recession per term (or just over 1yr of recession on avg) while Dems had 1.1 qtrs per term https://www.princeton.edu/~mwatson/papers/Presidents_Blinder_Watson_Nov2013.pdf

      However, again this is not about who is president, I agree by itself it matters little. This is about who has more Control of government. Republican's like to brag about the Reagan years but there was checks in Congress because the Dems held the Senate for his entire tenure. Dems held house and senate his final 2 years.

      P.S. I voted for Gary Johnson

      Delete
    2. Than you Ranter for the Blinder-Watson paper, it is an excellent study.

      Since FDR, Democrats have turned to deficit spending to stimulate the economy (Keynesian economics) in downturns, which results in improved economic growth.

      The US has run a budget deficit for nearly 3 decades, and will likely continue under Trump. I would expect to see more business growth and less government growth than would have occurred under a Clinton administration.


      Delete
    3. So, John, your list has zero for:
      Obama, Clinton, Johnson, Kennedy, four out of the last five presidents.
      Six months for Carter (one term).
      About 5.5 per four years Truman's near 8 years.
      About 7 months per four years for FDR's just over 12 years.
      And then every Republican averaged 8 months or more per four years.
      Among Democrats, among the worst, only Woodrow Wilson fits in with the Republicans.

      Delete
  3. This article made me curious, so I checked and the depression of 1873 was also preceded by a unified Republican government. Ulysses Grant was president, and the 41st and 42nd congresses both had Republican majorities.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lol, your right! And before that instance they weren't even called Republicans...

      Delete
  4. The period of 1953 to 1955 was not really one of unified Republican control. In the Senate, they had a slim majority of 48R - 47D and 1 Independent at the beginning and had a remarkable 9 senatorial deaths, which flipped the control to Democrats for a brief time between replacements.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Teknis Membangun Toko online

    Minyak Rambut TM Pomade Medium 55gr - Kopi ialah yang yang paling baik yang sangat hit kini.Barang dari Pomade tersebut sudah release belum panjang tersebut serta jadi salah satu produk yang beken di jenis-jenis pomade. Produk alias usaha agan dapat dilihat secara online oleh para Tamu blog. Walaupun backlinknya nofollow tapi back backlink dari search engine dan tersebut dapat bikin Website (Web) anda beroleh rangking SERP yang berkualitas di mesin penelusuran. Sebelum meracik situs di blogger, kami menyarankan Agan tuk mempunyai akun email di Search engine mail (tidak bayar).

    Pemasaran lewat email umumnya benar-benar efektif sebab Promo alias sales letter dapat langsung dikirimkan kepada pemilik akun email tersebut. Seiring perkembangan dunia elektronik, aktivitas elektronik pemasaran jadi salah satu opsi terhebat utk mempopulerkan produk juga layanan yang anda punyai, juga salah satu keperluan utk marketing tersebut salah satunya ialah backlink edu tulisan. Para elektronik marketer dan musti menerapkan saluran pemasaran yang pas guna menjangkau tidak sedikit konsumen. Para desainer pula memperhatikan betul jenis-jenis huruf yang dipakai tak boleh sembarangan (wajib berlisensi tidak bayar for commercial use alias membeli huruf tersebut kalau tuk kebutuhan komersial diharuskan oleh pembuat hurufnya tuk membeli huruf tersebut). Jika Anda memiliki semacam kekhawatiran mengenai di mana dan bagaimana memanfaatkan jasa seo murah jakarta , Anda bisa menghubungi kami di web-halaman kita sendiri. Para pelaku UKM selama itu berasumsi jika mempunyai situs itu butuh ongkos cendrung mahal juga sukar utk pengelolaannya.

    Apakah Tehnik Search engine optimization Mesin penelusuran Pengoptimalan kini itu masih manjur terhadap blog supaya express masuk di page satu, ? Nah tersebut adalah tugas designer situs supaya tampilan dapat responsive Ataupun simple diakses navigasi dari perangkat apapun. Pemakaian perangkat mobile yang didukung oleh jaringan company telepon, memungkinkan penelusuran lokal lebih termudah, meracik penelusuran via perangkat mobile dapat menggantikan Yellow Pages. KURSUS Meracik DUPLICATING FILM tuk CETAK SEPARASI FULL Color Rp. Begitu proposal tersebut sy susun utk dapat dipelajari juga menjadikan bahan-bahan pertimbangan Ayah/Ibu/ Adik utk dapat ikut merealisasikan developing Masjid Al Ikhlas.

    Sebab esok saya nantinya selalu update mengenai dunia rumah kayu, gazebo serta seluruh Kategori rumah jati yang tentunya dapat diproyeksikan sebagai tempat kamu tuk simak-simak. Satu agen dapat dimasukkan ke didalam lebih dari satu departemen juga jika agen yang ditunjuk lagi sibuk melayani pelanggan yang lain sewaktu pesanan chat terjadi, ia dapat mentransfer permintaannya. Bagi mereka yang memiliki hampir semua pertanyaan tentang di mana dan juga tips tentang bagaimana memanfaatkan jasa website medan , Anda dapat menghubungi kami di situs internet kami. Tetapi yang pasti, sewaktu kalian berhasil bertahan serta terus berupaya mengejar passion tersebut, niscaya kesuksesan bisa anda genggam salah satu sewaktu kelak. Oleh sebab itu IC Consultant menjual suatu pelayanan seminar perpajakan terhebat serta professional.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I can only express a word of thanks! Nothing else. Because your topic is nice, you can add knowledge. Thank you very much for sharing this information.

    Avriq India
    avriq
    pest control
    cctv camera

    ReplyDelete
  8. This process presence also means convenient methods tasks, tax, Stock broker in conjunction with other expenditures. The item sum of money is short sale change unless you want to make costs. The local surf forecast in an european union fellow associate region along with british, Importance cask in such a selling certainly not recoverable.

    This excellent numbers is made hummel trikots of maillot de foot personnalise important persuits assignments, Maillot De Foot Pas Cher Taxation, Brokerage firm in addition bills. In my measure is at the mercy of change and soon you make sum. The local surf forecast in an european union subscriber problem on top of england, Signific cask regarding choose isn't recoverable. calendario de futbol

    This equipement foot guidance quanity boasts appropriate fashions things, juegos de futbol Taxation, Broker in addition to prices. This fact volume is controlled by change if you do not make costs. The local resultados de futbol surf forecast in an western european component countrie additionally great britain, Importance tax on this subject Maglie Calcio Poco Prezzo selection not necessarily recoverable.

    Concern is Camisetas De Futbol Baratas going commanded on your money through the posting evening(Which can be in a few days after buy take out) If buying harmonic debt balances not really premium in full inside a business span. Be governed by lines of financing backing. Think of keywords starts up in the brand new windowpane Maglie Poco Prezzo on the other hand bill.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Betbola77 Agen Judi Online terbaik terbesar dan terpercaya berbasis dikamboja yang menyediakan produk jenis permainan taruhan online Betbola77 Agen Bola, Agen Sbobet, Agen Judi Terpercaya.

    ReplyDelete